Choose your decision
Bring your reasoning and material context. A sound position may survive scrutiny without objections.
Investment Thesis
Try to disprove the thesis before allocating capital.
Challenge this decision →Capital Allocation
Compare the next use of capital with real alternatives.
Challenge this decision →Business Investment
Separate business enthusiasm from investment economics.
Challenge this decision →Property Investment
Evaluate the property beyond the headline yield.
Challenge this decision →An investment thesis needs a downside and a falsifier
Separate factual data from assumptions about valuation, leverage, execution, management and durability. A persuasive story is incomplete without the conditions under which it would fail. Opportunity cost matters: compare the thesis with alternative uses of the same capital.
Capital Allocator examines allocation and economics. Investment Committee examines the thesis and evidence that could disconfirm it. For property or business investments, consider ongoing costs, liquidity, dependence on financing and what a disappointing outcome would do to your options.
An example to think through
Fictional example: an investor expects a property to fund itself. Test the supplied rental assumptions against maintenance, vacancy and financing costs, and specify what evidence would defeat the thesis.
Limits of this decision guide
This tool does not retrieve live prices by default, approve investments or guarantee performance. Supplied figures require verification. It is not personalized financial advice.
How objections change with evidence · Available analytical lenses
