Make your case
State the position, reasoning and material facts.
Devil’s Advocate sells intellectual resistance. Bring an idea, decision, argument, strategy or plan. Get a substantive critique, push back with evidence, and see whether an objection stands, changes or is resolved. A sound position may survive without objections.
State the position, reasoning and material facts.
Examine consequential objections and genuine strengths. Zero objections is valid.
Supply evidence and see whether the objection stands, revises or resolves.
State what you intend to do and why. Facts you report are labeled as reports; assumptions are not upgraded into verified evidence. The strongest support for your position matters alongside the strongest consequential concern.
STANDS: the consequential basis remains materially intact; new evidence may strengthen it. REVISED: evidence materially narrows, qualifies or changes the concern while a consequential issue remains. RESOLVED: evidence adequately defeats that specific basis.
A resolved concern should remain resolved unless genuinely new evidence establishes a materially new basis. Keeping the same decision is compatible with revising or resolving an objection. Changing a decision does not itself defeat an objection.
Stable objection IDs connect follow-ups with the original critique. Defend a valid concern, revise a weakened concern, and close a defeated concern. A sound idea can survive with zero objections.
The tool is designed for these behaviors, but AI can misapply them. If a critique repeats a defeated premise, push back with the relevant evidence. This methodology is not a claim of perfect model performance.
Threats, stalking, violence and coercive control interrupt ordinary adversarial framing. Safety support is not a paid upgrade. Do not use the tool to diagnose another person or encourage a dangerous confrontation.
Choose a decision domain · Privacy and retention · Challenge pricing